Reviewed by Juliet
Wittman
Sunday, February 2, 2003
Between Things
Jorge Ramos grew up in Mexico, where he began his
broadcast work while still a student. In 1981, he was sent to Washington, D.C., to cover
the attempted assassination of President Ronald Reagan; he was the only person on the
staff of his small radio station who spoke some English and had his passport in order.
But as he reports in No Borders: A Journalist's Search
for Home (Rayo, $24.95), he rapidly discovered that the media in Mexico were heavily
censored; he prepared a television segment in which prominent writers criticized the
government, and when the segment was rewritten, he left both his job and the country. His
first years in the United States, spent at the University of California in Los Angeles,
were a joyful, wide-eyed scramble. They were followed by broadcasting jobs, and eventually
Ramos became a newscaster at Noticiero Univision in Miami, now the most-watched
Spanish-language station in North America, where he won seven Emmys.
Ramos writes from the vantage point of a community that,
while remaining almost invisible to the mainstream media, is reshaping U.S. culture and
politics. He points out that North Americans hear far more about the Israeli-Palestinian
conflict, for example, than about the war in Colombia - though the latter has caused as
much carnage as the former and is closer to home.
No Borders is strongest when Ramos is talking about these
and other issues of identity. Treated like a foreigner in the United States, originally
vilified by Cubans in Florida for not being one of them, no longer fully identifying with
his Mexican roots, "I live without a home," he says, "and without
borders." Ramos is derisive about what he calls the "Christopher Columbus
syndrome," "the cyclical practice of 'discovering' Hispanics every time there is
a national election in the United States, and then almost completely forgetting about
us." Nonetheless, he mentions frequently and with approval the manner in which George
W. Bush courted Cuban voters in Florida, his attempts to speak Spanish and his role in the
Elian Gonzalez affair.
Although Ramos tells us he was moved to write this book
because it is impossible to do justice to complex issues on a television newscast, there's
a casual, conversational tone to the writing that skirts depth. The narrative sums up key
events rather than evoking them. Ramos visited Kosovo, interviewed a survivor of the El
Mozote massacre in El Salvador and stood at the site of the World Trade Center attack, but
he has nothing incisive to say about these experiences.
He does, however, powerfully evoke the plight of the
"sand children" he encountered after the recent war in Afghanistan: "Their
skin, cracked like dried dirt, looked as if it were about to break open. . . . Their hair
had become tough from years of wind, desert sand and the absence of shampoo and soap.
Their hands were brown and rough, like sandpaper. Their faces said five, six or seven
years old; their eyes, though, transmitted the anguish of an old person who had seen death
close up. They had never had a glass of milk or washed their faces with clean water." |